Aerial drone photo showing a small forested island (Protection Island) with homes, with many small boats anchored nearby

Protection Island

Jump to Listings Below

Protection Island is a rare and beautiful kind of place; it's rare because it's a little island (170 acres) right in the city's harbour, with no bridge leading to it. Imagine the result: a typical Georgia Strait island with tall forests and sandstone tidepools - waterfront homes, many of them quite affordable - only a 5-10 minute boat ride from downtown!

The catch? Access is by boat only. If that sounds totally awesome to you, then I'm really happy to tell you about Protection Island. I spent two amazing years on the Island, and would love to help you buy or sell a home there. Contact me or view Protection Island homes for sale below.

Photo showing 2 kids running on a rocky beach, Protection IslandIt's an extremely rare downtown waterfront property situation. Even though the island is "downtown", most areas are very quiet, the city noise being dulled by the thick forest that still covers most of the island. But you can take your canoe, skiff, kayak, yacht, or sailboat right into the downtown marina at any time. The crossing only takes 15 minutes by canoe, 10 minutes for a kayak, or 5 minutes for a power boat. But you don't need a boat; the passenger ferry takes just ten minutes and it runs hourly.

Family oriented: This is very much a Gulf Island, which means that alongside the retirees and their fancy boats, there are also lots of young families. School-day ferry passage for the local kids may be eligible for rebates (needs updated confirmation), kids 5 and under ride free, and the island's floating pub also has a restaurant area for families. The island is a wonderful place for kids to grow up.

Protection Island Properties for Sale

Sort by:
New
212 Captain Morgans Blvd, Protection Island

$599,900

212 Captain Morgans Blvd, Protection Island

0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 10,019 SqFt Lot Land MLS® # 1048025

Select Real Estate

New
23 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$529,000

23 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

2 Beds 1 Bath 916 SqFt 9,584 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1047936

Easy List Realty

New
164 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$248,000

164 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 9,148 SqFt Lot Land MLS® # 1047693

Century 21 Harbour Realty Ltd.

24 Pirate Pl, Protection Island

$915,000

24 Pirate Pl, Protection Island

4 Beds 2 Baths 1,527 SqFt 9,148 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1044086

Macdonald Realty Westmar - Richmond

192 Colvilleton Trail, Protection Island

$660,000

192 Colvilleton Trail, Protection Island

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,332 SqFt 7,841 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1041861

Royal LePage Nanaimo Realty (NanIsHwyN)

182 Colvilleton Trail, Protection Island

$725,000

182 Colvilleton Trail, Protection Island

2 Beds 2 Baths 1,042 SqFt 9,584 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1041931

Royal LePage Nanaimo Realty (NanIsHwyN)

8 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$3,200,000

8 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,655 SqFt 12,197 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1041546

U1 Real Estate Services Corportation

19 Captain Morgans Blvd, Protection Island

$350,000

19 Captain Morgans Blvd, Protection Island

2 Beds 1 Bath 768 SqFt 9,584 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1040350

Pemberton Holmes Ltd. (Nanaimo)

137 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$649,000

137 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

0 Beds 0 Baths 0 SqFt 19,602 SqFt Lot Land MLS® # 1040939

Pemberton Holmes Ltd. (Nanaimo)

137 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$1,548,000

137 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,609 SqFt 28,750 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1040799

Pemberton Holmes Ltd. (Nanaimo)

8 Pirate Pl, Protection Island

$899,000

8 Pirate Pl, Protection Island

4 Beds 3 Baths 2,609 SqFt 9,148 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1040497

Pemberton Holmes Ltd. (Nanaimo)

7 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

$829,900

↓ $20,000

7 Pirates Lane, Protection Island

2 Beds 1 Bath 738 SqFt 20,038 SqFt Lot Single Family Detached MLS® # 1039381

REMAX Professionals (NA)

Protection Island Homes

In the past few years, Protection Island real estate has seen an increase in value commensurate with the general trends of the region. Yet the island's lifestyle is still coloured by those whose ancestors settled here, and nature-loving retirees, and hipster students with a passion for each morning's crossing by kayak, on their way to the university.

The home styles on the island are a hodge-podge of log homes, cottages, waterfront cabins, luxury homes, and crafty bungalows, scattered along the island's few (gravel) streets. The island is connected to the city's water and sewer (see sewer comments below), and has full power/hydro as well as phone and cable access. The City of Nanaimo zoning for the island (R3) is low-density, only permitting one home per lot. Mobile homes and RVs are not permitted.


Aerial photo showing an island lit by the setting sun

There are some great parks here. Most people who daytrip to the island will ride over on the ferry or in their own watercraft, park at the floating Dinghy Dock Pub, and then decide whether to visit the pub/restaurant before or after they walk around the island.

Photo of Spyglass Lookout park on Protection Island with the City of Nanaimo visible across the harbour

You can walk to Newcastle Island from Protection Island at low tide! In fact, planning to visit Protection at the lowest tides is a great idea, especially if you want to enjoy sunny weather at the very north or very south ends of the island. Did I mention I once swam to Protection Island?

I wrote this to someone who was asking about life on the island:

"It's a great island – I think it's under-valued because it's relatively unknown. Nowhere else can you get a lifestyle so close to the water, WITH city water and sewer, without paying MUCH more.
Cons:
-You can never just rush for groceries or the hospital without getting in a boat. But, you will know people with boats who are happy to drive you to the hospital anytime.
-If someone invites you to do something in Nanaimo, you are more likely to say "Nah, I'm staying on the island"
-If you buy a new couch, you have to figure out how to get it home!
-In bad weather you could be stuck.

Pros:
-Beaches are a 10min walk at MOST – you will soon have a collection of driftwood and shells in your yard.
-It's a gentle paradise in good weather, with herons croaking and sunlight reflecting off the water, lighting up the arbutuses.
-Seems like a great long term investment "

About the Sewer (Sanitary) Connection

The system used on Protection Island is a hybrid "STEP" system - that stands for Septic Tank Effluent Pump. It's a hybrid setup where the waste is stored in a holding tank on your property where the solids can settle at the bottom and everything else goes into the City pipe. You are required to pump out the tank every 2-5 years which requires a truck to be barged over, but of course Island residents can pool resources so they aren't EACH paying for a truck to be barged over!

Protection Island Location

Access to the island is either via your own boat, or by a little passenger-only ferry that runs from the marina near Port Place Mall. Residents get massively discounted rates on the ferry by pre-purchasing punch cards that don't expire.

Back to top